Standard Gear, no prep. Barristan and Oberyn all lies on if Robert or Jaime can kill Oberyn in time to save their partner. Please submit your votes for the debate moderator, champion for Robert Baratheon, champion for Barristan Selmy, and setting for our seventh and final debate. There is an illustrative scene in A Game of Thrones when King Robert hurls his breastplate at nearby Ser Barristan, but Selmy calmly dodges. Barristan y Robert Baratheon tras la Batalla del Tridente (Histories & Lore) Durante la Guerra del Usurpador, tras la derrota de Lord Jon Connington en la Batalla de las Campanas, Barristan y Ser Jonothor Darry fueron enviados a replegar las fuerzas de Connington. The idea is that the warrior will be transported to the scene. To view the debate in its proper format click "Sort by: old". ), New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I'm not denying it but that's not why I think Team 1 will win. added by vici-mercedes. The most likely and most discussed matchup is Big Bob Vs. Pokey Stick and Incest Boy Vs. Aegon decisively headed towards it and sat upon the kingly seat. I think most people would agree Robert is the better warrior (not by a lot mind you), but Oberyn might have the right style to win. I dothink that Jaime could and would hold Ser Barristan off long enough for Robert to join and kill Barristan with the help of The Kingslayer. Sneaker high schwarz - Whlen Sie dem Favoriten Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 - Umfangreicher Produktratgeber Die besten Favoriten Aktuelle Angebote Testsieger JETZT direkt weiterlesen! Almost too fair for a definitive victory. The t.v Jaime beats t.v Oberyn in a very tough fight. Created by @MeereeneseKnot, The Great Castles of Westeros: An Unofficial Guide by Joe Buckley, The Unofficial Guide to Game of Thrones by Kim Renfro, Try LISTENING to ASOIAF! 2 Barristan Selmy. Nominations will close at 8:00 am on September 2. I love Jaime Lannister but a prime Barristan could fight Arthur Dayne to a stand still (given that Dayne doesn't have Dawn). To submit a question for the Floor Debate, send a PM to debate moderator Jen_Snow . On a side note, I'm happy my prediction came true. . When the commander of an army goes down then the battle is over. Selmey and Oberyn with perfect teamwork would be RAD to watch. During a tourney at Storm's End, Robert was defeated by Ser Barristan Selmy. (As in, nominate yourself for moderator by replying to my top level comment that says Debate Moderator Nominations and so on.). It then kicks off. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Ridiculous ones were discarded. Next thread I will have to make sure to specify. Killing Rhaegar at the Battle of . One of the closest battle threads I've seen. Though Robert is a sheer mass of brute force, Barristan is the most acclaimed fighter in all of Westeros. I don't doubt that Barristan could kill either 9/10 but his teammate has to survive for Barristan to stand a chance otherwise it's a 2 Vs. 1 situation where Selmy has no chance of winning. But thanks, it means the world to me. Team 1, Oberyn is too much of a weak link. To illustrate: If Kings Landing 275 AL is chosen as the debate setting, you wont be arguing that a 3 year old Sandor Clegane is the better warrior than a 21 year old Jorah Mormont. That said team two for an eventual win, Barriston is just too good in his youth. Press J to jump to the feed. La misin fracas, y Steffon, acompaado por su esposa, volvieron a casa. Votes dont count here. Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 Detaillierter Test Die besten Batterien tiptoi Beste Angebote Preis-Leistungs-Sieger. The question is, who wins the other fight. Barristan Selmy was the Lord Commander of the Kingsguard, the elite bodyguard of the King of the Andals and the First Men. I don't think Jaime could do the same. Seeing her strong sense of honour, I see her sticking with her duel. If Jaime takes Oberyn then I think his team should win more often than not because he should defeat Oberyn fast than Barristan defeats Robert and then go for the 2v1. (Spoilers Main) Who is this Celtigar woman missing an eye? The TV series has an illustrative scene in which King Robert, Lord Commander Selmy, and Ser Jaime Lannister discuss their first kills. Ser Barristan's arms and armor are no different than those of Rhaegar Targaryen, whom Robert defeated. Ser Barristan Selmy, also called Barristan the Bold, is a knight from House Selmy and the Lord Commander of the Kingsguard of Robert I Baratheon. Achilles(Troy) vs Arthur Dayne, Barristan Selmy and Robert Baratheon Battle Fight takes place near the Tower of Joy. Barristan "the Bold" Selmy recounts how he was named to the Kingsguard, saw King Aerys descend into madness but revered Prince Rhaegar Targaryen. When the King briefly glared at him, Ser Barristan couldn't help but shrink away. It wasn't even forged yet when he was in his prime lol. Archaeologist believe that it comes from the late fourth century, many wonder if this might be perhaps the missing tombs of Lord Renly Baratheon and his wife, Celia Hightower. A Song of Ice and Fire: The Novels welches bedeutet auch, dass wir die erste Garde der jeweiligen Test- oder Vergleichsparameter stets hinterfragen und sehr wenige Datenpunkte nur dann in die . The reason Robert killed Rhaegar is he landed 1 hit to the chest that did enough damage to go through all of the Targaryen's armour and kill him. cersei and meryn trant. You can include a short sales pitch too if you'd like. Behind him, standing erect, was Ser Meryn Trant. Barristan Selmy vs. Robert Baratheon The Latest News Discussing Episode 9, "The Green Council" Folio Society Releases A Dance with Dragons Illustrated Edition Two Weeks Until The Rise of the Dragon Discussing Episode 8, "The Lord of the Tides" The Catspaw Dagger at the Game of Thrones Studio Tour Notable Releases It can be believed that Robert being the fighter he was would of commanded the va. Jump to content. And if either Lion or Stag could put down Ser Barristan Selmy, than that would guarantee their teams victory. Selmy and Oberyn have great finesse aspects to their fighting styles, and I think they outclass Robert in that regard, and Selmy outclasses Jaime at swordsmanship. Cite This Page The sequences would entail Robert beating Oberyn and Jaime either dying to Barristan or stalling him long enough to where the Stag can join the Lion and kill Ol' Selmy. (Spoilers Extended) Ironborn, Dornish and Young Griff are (Spoilers Extended) Map of known world if it was as big (Spoilers Main) How does Ned know about Jaime and Cersei? An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works The book Jaime slaughter's book Oberyn. I think Robert and Jaime take this one: either of them could at least hold their own against Selmy for a considerable time - time enough for the other to take Oberyn down, I reckon. Two free book downloads plus a 30 day subscription for $0 (Audible trial), House of the Dragon S1: Episode 10 Review, House of the Dragon S1: Episode 10 Preview, A Hymn for Spring (Tower of the Hand, includes an essay on Harrenhal by us! The issue is Viper v. Big Bob. Maybe the OP can help me out, am I interpreting the rules incorrectly. Also remember that Oberyn's poison was fairly slow acting against the Mountain and this is their standard gear, so if we assume he gets poison, than it would be the poison showcased, slow acting. Robert Baratheon. Selmey beats Jamie - no doubt, but it could take some time. Unsere besten Auswahlmglichkeiten - Suchen Sie die Wonderclean entsprechend Ihrer Wnsche. mit Mithilfe des Preisverlaufs erkennst du zgig, OB in normaler Schrift ein guter Datum fr den Akquisition ist oder OB es sich lohnt, noch ein paar . I'd say this match up is closer to even because it's hardness to call. The Pardon of Barristan Selmy by King Robert Baratheon After the Battle of the Trident, Robert Baratheon, Eddard Stark and others had a decision on their hands. Setting winner is obvious, I'm more curious to see who wins for champions and debate moderator! 2022 GAMESPOT, A FANDOM COMPANY. However, the better way for Jaime would be to survive. Ugh, I keep going back and forth, leaning towards team 2, Without reading books my gut feeling is Oberyn and Selmy. Oberyn is well suited to Robert's type (to a lesser degree than Gregor) and is more likely to draw first blood, resulting in a poisoned Robert, which secures Oberyn the fight. Check back then to see who will be debating! Robert is like a smaller faster version of the Mountain. Robert killed Rhaegar but Barristan is far superior in swordplay. Add Jaime if you cant see the trio winning and Dawn for Dayne. Here are the nominees for Roberts champion. Robert, a great warrior and charismatic man in his youth, took the throne through conquest in the war known as Robert's Rebellion, which began when the Prince of Dragonstone, Rhaegar Targaryen, allegedly abducted Robert's betrothed, Lyanna Stark. There is no limit to how many times a person can consecutively serve as moderator. Then, anyone who has read the books goes.ehhhhhhh, but Robert in his prime doesnt exactly sound slow by any means and is probably the better overall warrior. But gun pointed at your head, you have to choose your gut choice. If Jaime fights Barristan then things get a lot more interesting. Voting will take place tomorrow. His skill was so legendary, he was knighted at the age of 16 by King Aegon V after competing in a King's Landing tournament as a mystery knight, defeating the Lord Commander of the Kingsguard at. People can accompany their nomination by a short "sales pitch" (200 word maximum), describing why someone should vote for you or your proposed setting. Barristan is a member of House Selmy, a minor house of the Stormlands, that serves House Baratheon of Storm's End. Jaime having a Valyiran steel sword inches him ever so much closer to Barristan and possibly puts them as equals. Let's see how people talk about Robert Baratheon from the old days (paraphrased from the book. George was in my town so of course I had to say hello (NO [Spoilers Extended] Not sure if this has been mentioned [Spoilers Extended] I appreciate how George uses archers (Spoilers Extended) I really hope House of the Dragon (Spoilers Main) The show is not pro-black or pro-green ( spoiler extended ) Westeros and Essos satellite style [Spoilers Main] Prominent sigils shown in House of the (No Spoilers) New Interview With GRRM Confirms HBO Passed (spoilers main) Why doesnt Tywin take another wife and [spoilers main] how good of a fighter was Ned Stark? That being said, the young Robert of the rebellion was a beast. Wow, there's some crazy competition for moderator and the debaters! Waiting for him there is Barristan Selmy fully aware of Robert's cold blooded murder of the children. battle here. It can be a few words or up to 50. Everyone can feel the tension. In the Great Hall, Robert smiles at the dead bodies of Rhaegar's children and Ser Barristan can't control his anger. Please reply here to nominate yourself to be the champion debating on behalf of Robert Baratheon, during Roberts Rebellion. A fresh sea breeze competes with the remnants of last night's burnt bowl of brown. A celebrated hero, he has served since a time when the Kingsguard were considered the greatest knights of the Seven Kingdoms. Now it's one on one. Team 2 wins ever so slightly imo, Selmey in his prime would be something else~. He is beyond proficient and would defeat Robert. Barristan Selmy was tall and slender with very blue eyes. A prime Jaime Lannister can not take out a prime Barristan Selmy. The top of the wall. The hypothetical is pretty unlikely in my opinion. Remember, bothof them are in their prime and Jaime isn't a slouch in any sense. Fury was building in him, Barristan could tell that much. Jaime could cut off the spear very similar to how the Mountain did and he wouldn't be brutish and uncaring with his strikes. The moderator sets the pace of the debate and chooses which questions will be asked. Then you think, Oberyn is probably a smarter fighter and was an undefeated pit fighter and sell-sword. But I think Oberyn would be able to take Prime Robert Baratheon with how well he was handling the Mountain until he starting being stupid. Dieser tritt in ihre Dienste und berichtet ihr, dass Jorah Mormont fr Robert spioniert hat. Why would he exert that much energy against a light weapon that he knowns is being wielded by one of the greatest Westerosi swordsmen. CONTEXT Robert Baratheon Let's first take a look at Robert. I wanted to vote for the flat patch of land but had to go with my fantasy choice. Jaime beats Oberyn before Barristan can overcome Robert in a Barristan vs Robert/Jaime vs Oberyn matchup. Photo of Barristan Selmy for fans of House Baratheon 30082550. Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 Detaillierter Test Beliebteste Wonderclean Aktuelle Angebote Alle Preis-Leistungs-Sieger Direkt lesen! I'm slightly leaning towards Selmy and Oberyn mostly because I think Oberyn is too fast and sneaky for Robert. It's standard gear, and since Widow's Wail really never was his standard in his combat days, I will say no Widow's Wail. In the street, out side a pot shop in Flea Bottom. But if you want to put it all down to numbers, Team 1 has the superior amount and thus the greater chance of getting the win. General (ASoIaF) A Forum of . (Rhaegar had won tourneys, not battles.) Close or exact matches were combined. House Baratheon Club Join New Post. Either Oberyn makes a mistake or he finds a spot in Robert's armor and finishes him. The only people allowed to post in here are the two champions and the debate moderator. Barristan the Bold, one of the greatest knights in the realm, lay badly wounded after suffering 3 or more wounds during the fighting. The strength difference is negated by his use of the warhammer though he might have trouble punishing Oberyn's offensive since the likelihood of Oberyn losing his spear is lowered by Robert's use of a warhammer over a sword. Robert is either more capable of dealing with Barristan than Jaime or less so. My money's on Team 1. Answer (1 of 38): "King" Robert was fat and nearly useless, but even then he managed to kill a huge boar after being fatally gored by it. Robert's war hammer is an immensely cumbersome weapon that would wear him down with time, and Ser Barristan is capable of dodging his blows. The speed advantage wouldn't be as big of a factor as it was vs. Gregor and Barristan likely has more raw skill. Ser Barristan Selmy, also known as Barristan the Bold and Arstan Whitebeard, is an anointed knight of House Selmy. These four are exceptional fighters, but I've always considered Oberyn to be marginally beneath the likes of Jaime. Both had inklings at being good leader-types in battle. With Robert, Oberyn can still use his advantages of agility but with it being less useful than what he would against Gregor Clegane. Btw, I was starting to do one each day, but it seems like I don't have to do that anymore. @the_red_viper: From my understanding of the thread. At present his current gear is Widow Wail and his best feats are from his prime times in the books. Depends on if Oberyn used poison I guess. Barristan beating Jaime 9/10 Barristan beating both Jaime and Robert 0/10, The less discussed and least likely pairing would be the Lion of Lannister Vs. Mods reserve final say on whether a setting is workable or not. Broad daylight, crisp and clear. If Cersei/Jaime demanded a trial-by-combat Robert would have faced Jaime, not some Kingsguard. In this case, Jaime would win. Now, Ser Barristan faces a more formidable opponent in his future king, Robert Baratheon--a feared warrior and battle commander. Only replies to the top level comment categories will be considered. @the_red_viper: @cdiddyman911: If that's the case then the gap between Jaime and Barristan gets a little wider. 7 Loras Tyrell. Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 - Detaillierter Ratgeber TOP Produkte Aktuelle Schnppchen Vergleichssieger Direkt ansehen. In the throne room, as Tywin places the babies in front of Robert. It is damning. That said the poison on his spear would eventually get him a win but not before a long hard battle. The Tower of Joy, Lyanna's screams coming from above the tower, and only Ser Selmy left. Held his own briefly against the Smiling Knight as a teenager. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Comments are in random ordering and vote scores are hidden. He served as a member of the Kingsguard to Kings Jaehaerys II and Aerys II Targaryen. It is feats and gear from the show and the books. However, in 278 AC, his parents died when their ship, the Windproud, was caught in a storm; Robert, standing on the walls of Storm's End with Stannis, witnessed his parents' ship that was returning from Essos break up on the rocks of Shipbreaker Bay. Settings have to be workable. Barristan Selmy details how Robert's Rebellion was a pivotal war for House . Here are the nominees for debate moderator. Durante un torneo en Bastin de Tormentas, Robert fue derrotado por Ser Barristan Selmy. Please reply here to nominate a scene or setting for this debate. Until she'd fall. Well done. The Red Viper would have a harder time with Robert then he did the mountain. Metallklebeband - Unsere Favoriten unter allen analysierten Metallklebeband. 02 Nov 2022 19:56:06