Penn & Teller: Fool Us kicked off its new season earlier this week, but next Monday’s show might be the highlight of season five. It features previous winners of the coveted FU Trophy coming in to try for a repeat. There are (obviously) some familiar faces in the episode trailer, but I didn’t see Shawn Farquhar and don’t think I am alone in wanting to see him come and go for the three-peat!

If you missed the season five premiere, it is streaming for free over on The CW website. They are also running it again Friday night after the season premiere of The CW’s other magic show Masters Of Illusion.