Paul Carr The Strip Diary Day Thirty One Enough Has Been Written On the Awfulness of Criss Angel So Here s a Video

In what will surely become a rallying cry for Angel haters and taken as a declaration of war by Camp Criss and his army of Loyals, we introduce Paul Carr’s 12-minute video review of Criss Angel Believe.

Due to some foul language we can’t embed the video here. So go ahead and click through to Paul’s blog to view it.

It’s about as brutal of a reaction as we’ve seen or read since the early days of the show when every and any one tee’d off on the wayward Cirque collaboration. It’s also in marked difference to the newer slew of reviews which indicated the show had greatly improved.

What seems to be a consistent sticking point through write-ups good and bad is Angel humor. At it’s best ribald and worst spine-rattlingly creepy, gags featuring Criss and female audience members have often been singled out by critics haranguing Angel for his stage presence and patter.

To those asking why we are running a bad review of a show now. We can explain:

Criss, as he has been for the entirety of this site’s existence is the most debated figure in magic, which has spilled out into mainstream. It’s a feat only a handful of magicians, probably under 10, have ever accomplished. Thus, a review like this will be sought after and viewed hundreds (if not thousands) of times within the magic community alone.

Carr will likely be dismissed as a man with a grudge or someone who doesn’t get it by Angel fans. He’ll be sainted by those who hate Criss. Either are probably true, but both are the pretexts for why you’re watching.

  • Thor

    Hal won’t even know what to do with himself after watching this review lol.

  • Magi

    Comical – wow what an obvious personal attack – maybe CA slept with his GF if he had one…

  • Gracy_hm

    This made me smile. I think there is market for every type of performance. Some people will go to Angel some won’t. Its not my cup of tea but if you love it more power to you. Give me 100 million dollars and I can make a show equal or greater than I guarantee it!

  • FriendinFlorida

    All I gotta say is, been pretty icy since Rainey got hit. Black jack anyone?

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F_O2Lw0wuSA&feature=related

  • Luke

    Personally I think it’s pretty sad that Criss’ Make-A-Wish post only got 1 comment but when it comes to something negative people have no problem jumping all over it. You certainly can’t please everyone all the time but when there’s positive you should get the same credit/attention of when something negative appears.

    Just sayin’….

  • http://www.techwoodn.com/ garden decking

    It’s really a very good article?thanks

  • FriendinFlorida

    Oh Mr. Dancy. I appreciate your view. But..but there is so much you dont know. I posted a thousand positives for MANY years, fought the LV reporters and everyone else. But let me post one critical comment?

    Just sayin…how can you lobby for this when the fans arent treated the same?

  • Steve Chezaday

    I think he should tell us what he really thinks of Criss Angel …

  • Ruse

    Is it true that Criss walked out in the middle of one of his performances? Any reports to back that up?

  • Magi

    Luke you are 100% correct! Obviously itricks has proven their negative bias to CA, over and over again. Even when they write their own copy it always seems to slant with a negative overtone. When your the king of the mountain your always a target – no doubt – but you would think after watching this ridiculous video that a magic outlet would recognize that its a personal attack with a hidden agenda (it doesn’t even make sense) and is not based with any facts to back it up. This is a reviewer calling someone a “Dbag”? Are you kidding me! Why would Itricks/Kaufman help spread this garbage. If it were DC, PT, or any other famous magician -itricks would NEVER post it. Instead of appreciating someone who is promoting the art we all love and is hugely successful in doing so. Itricks and Kaufman help spread negativity, personal attacks and hidden agendas. It’s probably why Itricks has about 5,000 unique visitors a year – pathetic! Furthermore it’s why you don’t see the below BBC amazing review or countless other positive stories about CA posted here. Itricks everything comes with a price – you just have to ask yourself if the price will be worth it…

    “Believe A+ by far the most spectacular & amazing magic show in Vegas & I’ve seen them all!” -The BBC http://celebrityradio.co.uk/?p=4037

  • http://iTricks.com/news JustinRYoung

    Magi, I can very honestly and personally say that me or anyone at iTricks
    has any kind of negative bias toward Criss. We’ve repeatedly ran almost
    every news story that comes down the pike about CA, for the simple fact that
    he makes the most news. By that formula, he’s going to make the most
    negative news by volume.

    I editorialized a few months ago about how everyone needs to face facts
    about how Believe was a much improved show.
    http://itricks.com/news/2011/03/face-facts-all-evidence-suggests-criss-angel-believe-is-a-good-magic-show/

    Behind the scenes via email, I caught a ton of flack from professional
    magicians and readers asking me how much Angel paid for the commercial. I
    responded that it was solely my opinion and one that I stood by.

    The above review ran because I determined if readers didn’t watch it here
    they would have watched it somewhere else. We aim to bring them the magic
    news first. I personally think it’s petty and mean, but then again, I think
    that about most negative reviews. Others, (read: readers) find value in it.
    So we run it.

    Furthermore, as I noted in the copy, this was the first negative review
    we’ve read in a while. I’d rather people see it in that context than to
    ignore the year and half of great press Believe has gotten.

    Luke, I totally concur. For all the venom spewed Criss’ way he should be
    recognized for his charitable efforts. He’s the biggest name in magic and
    he’s using it to give back. That means something. That’s why we run any
    information we see on that kind of stuff.

    At the end of the day: I like Criss. I like his team. I like Luke. I like
    Joe. Everyone on Team Angel I’ve met has been very nice to me and the site.
    We just try and cover the scarce amount of magic news that trickles through
    as best we can. If it is someone’s opinion that we are doing a crap job of
    it, so be it. I hope we can win them back at some point down the road.

    p.s. I do want to point out that Richard Kaufman has nothing to do with
    iTricks, although I am sure he’s throw up on his shoes if he read himself
    lumped in with a stupid little blog like this.

  • http://iTricks.com/news JustinRYoung

    Magi, I can very honestly and personally say that me or anyone at iTricks
    has any kind of negative bias toward Criss. We’ve repeatedly ran almost
    every news story that comes down the pike about CA, for the simple fact that
    he makes the most news. By that formula, he’s going to make the most
    negative news by volume.

    I editorialized a few months ago about how everyone needs to face facts
    about how Believe was a much improved show.
    http://itricks.com/news/2011/03/face-facts-all-evidence-suggests-criss-angel-believe-is-a-good-magic-show/

    Behind the scenes via email, I caught a ton of flack from professional
    magicians and readers asking me how much Angel paid for the commercial. I
    responded that it was solely my opinion and one that I stood by.

    The above review ran because I determined if readers didn’t watch it here
    they would have watched it somewhere else. We aim to bring them the magic
    news first. I personally think it’s petty and mean, but then again, I think
    that about most negative reviews. Others, (read: readers) find value in it.
    So we run it.

    Furthermore, as I noted in the copy, this was the first negative review
    we’ve read in a while. I’d rather people see it in that context than to
    ignore the year and half of great press Believe has gotten.

    Luke, I totally concur. For all the venom spewed Criss’ way he should be
    recognized for his charitable efforts. He’s the biggest name in magic and
    he’s using it to give back. That means something. That’s why we run any
    information we see on that kind of stuff.

    At the end of the day: I like Criss. I like his team. I like Luke. I like
    Joe. Everyone on Team Angel I’ve met has been very nice to me and the site.
    We just try and cover the scarce amount of magic news that trickles through
    as best we can. If it is someone’s opinion that we are doing a crap job of
    it, so be it. I hope we can win them back at some point down the road.

    p.s. I do want to point out that Richard Kaufman has nothing to do with
    iTricks, although I am sure he’s throw up on his shoes if he read himself
    lumped in with a stupid little blog like this.

  • Magi

    Justin have YOU seen his show lately? If not and you do this for a living, you might want to see it for yourself or are you concerned if you do, and it is a great show, that it will ruin your ability to post crap.

  • http://iTricks.com/news JustinRYoung

    I have seen the show every time I have been in Vegas since it opened.
    Unfortunately, that has not happened in the last year or so. When I am back
    there, I am anxious to see Believe.

    I feel like I’ve represented that the critical community had completely
    turned around on Believe on iTricks. I ran all the recent positive reviews
    and then wrote an editorial marking the trend. I don’t know anyone else who
    covers the magic industry that has done the same. When I see Believe again
    (which I have already seen twice) I am guessing that I’ll have the same
    positive reaction as some of the other critics. But my taste is not law and
    there are others who might think of full of it, so if there is another
    opinion out there I would feel compelled to run it so readers didn’t think I
    was hiding anything from them.

    Let me state unequivocally: I root for all magicians. I root for Criss
    Angel. I root for all magic shows. I root for Believe.

  • Joe Monti

    Magi,
    I agree that it’s sad that positive Angel news gets few comments and hate rants for CA gets regurgitated everywhere regardless of wether its an educated critique or the howling of wanna-be reviewers (like the Huffington post Jihad against anything Criss Angel).
    I do think that Justin R Young has tried his best to highlight Angel news in a much better light than all other sources. It can’t always be sunny but Justin has been fair.
    News is news and “Magic” news outlets need content. Unfortunately amateur
    magicians have time to pick apart professionals and that’s “content” I guess. Sad.

    Most will say I’m biased because I work with Criss and I kinda am but bottom line
    is I like good magic and the believe show is fantastic. If CA wasn’t famous because of his TV show and was a newcomer with his LUXOR show I truly feel that most magicians and lay people would flip the f**k out at the amount and quality of Magic in BELIEVE.
    CA worked hard to turn the show, and many critics, 180 degrees. Would a loser have the skill or devote that much personal time to do that? I don’t think so. Magic shows come and go in LV because the performers don’t have the skill, vision or dedication to making it better. I applaud Criss Angel for working hard and successfully achieving what most thought couldn’t be done.
    Justin, you’re a smart guy. I know your job is difficult as well trying to balance the news. You’ll get picked on but you work hard and you’ve done your own kind of Magic.
    I think you and CA should work together somehow. There’s an ugly world out there and somebody’s got to make it prettier.
    Always listening cause my smile is glistening :)
    Joe Monti

  • FriendinFlorida

    Actually Joe, JRY did the Criss Angel podcast on this site for a very long time until I think it was deemed that it should go under CAs own site and was pulled by Team Angel.

    And I think we can all agree on one thing. Justin does rock. :)

  • http://iTricks.com/news JustinRYoung

    Not quite. We did an unofficial podcast for a while. Then CA’s team wanted
    us to do an official one, which we did on their site. Then they decided they
    didn’t want to contract out anymore. No harm no foul.

  • http://iTricks.com/news JustinRYoung

    Not quite. We did an unofficial podcast for a while. Then CA’s team wanted
    us to do an official one, which we did on their site. Then they decided they
    didn’t want to contract out anymore. No harm no foul.

  • joe monti

    JRY does rule but he is in a position that could be misread. When I did stand-up comedy I worked with a comic that would make acerbic, edgy jokes that sometimes made the audience boo. The comic replied, “I’m just a reporter”. Great reply. Laughs continued.

  • Magi

    FACT- Paul Carr is an alcoholic, addicted to prostitutes who known to ride the backs of celebs to get attention with bias sensationalism

  • JustinM

    And the bashing continues! Part 3,000. I’ve been hearing that Criss Angel sucks and his show won’t survive. And yet, Criss Angel is still going strong and continues to improve his show. People need to realize that Criss Angel is here to stay. Like him or not, respect the fact that he has come this far in his career.

  • FriendinFlorida

    I am trying Joe…that is why I am still here. Thank you for your words.