skitched-20091111-034120.jpg

Do autistic audience members see through a magician’s sleight of hand more than others? That is what a new study is suggesting as covered by ABC News yesterday.

But at least two magicians fired back on their Twitter accounts, casting doubt on the findings. Apollo Robbins, who is quoted in the ABC article, had the following comment.

They say autistic subjects often see through magic, but their example has a false solution. They need a magic-proofer :)

Meanwhile, David Blaine confederate Doug Mackenzie took a harsher tone.

By sentence 3, you know the article is BS …

For the record, here are the first three sentences of the article:

The magician placed a coin atop an airtight rubber seal on a cup and — abracadabra — the shiny piece fell to the bottom of the cup.

But he didn’t fool 8-year-old Stephen Shore, who was the only one among his fellow Boy Scouts who saw through the magic trick.

“People didn’t see the slit in the piece of rubber,” said Shore, now 48 and an assistant professor of special education teacher at New York’s Adelphi University. “I went up and just kind of pushed my finger into the slit.”

What do you folks think?

  • Very good and extremely true quote:

    "...it's a magical place to retreat to if you have autism."
  • Tim Ellis
    I have Asperger's myself and, as my wife Sue-Anne said, "I don't know how there could be answers to autism in magic... rather, it's a magical place to retreat to if you have autism."
  • I agree with Andrew, nobody figured out the method here. The kid created a fictional memory about how he "saw through" the trick, and the reporter ate it up without even doing the most basic research.

    Wait a second, media covering the hype rather than the facts about autism? How unusual...
  • friendinflorida
    Geesh,, the one kid figured it out who just happens to be autistic. Me thinks this magician needs to work on his misdirection instead of looking for excuses.
  • The fact that the kid (and obviously the reporter) doesn't know how the trick works and created a very elaborate fantasy of both a mechanism and how he detected it is far more interesting then the point the reporter is trying to make.

    While I think that there's little argument that an autistic person would be less susceptible to certain kinds of social misdirection, trying to make them all mini-geniuses that see through visual misdirection can be very harmful to them and their treatment.

  • Facebook User
    "An estimated 1 in 150 children -- or about 1 percent of all children -- are diagnosed with autism spectrum disorders"

    1 in 150 is not "about 1% of all children" at all, it's about 0.67%, which is about 33% lower than 1%, meaning the aforementioned article is about 99% bullcrap.
  • MadGeorge
    I was just on a front page article in the paper about a similar subject where I’m teaching a child with Aspergers syndrome which is a form of autism.
    Let me state this fact in no way shape or form does my student see through the trick in fact I find that it’s the opposite, he just doesn’t care sometimes.
  • timothydrake
    Media and Magic do not mix. Media will put any spin on it that suits them.. just like any other article they ever print. LOL

    I remember the time an AP reporter called Walter Blaney for his thoughts on the Houdini Museums exposure of one of Harrys classics. He insured Walter he would not allow any exposures in the article yet when it went to print it read something like this.. " Magicians like Walter Blaney are upset that the Museum is exposing the secret trap door used in the effect."

    Yep... you can ALWAYS trust a reporter. ;) NOT!
blog comments powered by Disqus